Crime and Self-Punishment

Alia Shawkat

Hannah Rayburn

Mae Whitman

Emma 'Grace' McKee

Erica Yohn

Grandma Ida

Dinah Manoff

Evelyn Rayburn

Michael Mantell

David Rayburn

Faye Grant

Tattie McKee

Jason Blicker

Uncle Heschie

Frances McDormand

Adult Hannah (voice)

Bonnie Bailey-Reed

Shirley

Patricia Forte

Cookie

Kevin Ramsey

Ernie

Ann Walker

Maitland

Patrick Thomas O'Brien

Bill

Biff Wiff

Bob

John C. McDonnell

Roy

Jane A. Johnston

Lucy

Elizabeth Densmore

Jessica

Nicole Fellows

Janine